Is My Non-Compete Clause Enforceable? UK Law Explained
Non-compete clauses are common in UK employment contracts — but many are unenforceable. Here's how to tell whether yours would hold up in court, and what you can do about it.
Can your employer force you back to the office? Can you request remote work permanently? Here's what UK employment law says about working from home, flexible working requests, and your rights.
Millions of UK employees now work remotely, either full-time or in a hybrid arrangement. But the legal framework around home working is widely misunderstood — and many employees don't know whether they can insist on it, how to request it formally, or what happens if their employer tries to change an existing arrangement.
There is no automatic, unqualified right to work from home in UK law. Whether you can work remotely depends on:
However, several important legal principles limit an employer's ability to force you back to the office or refuse remote working entirely.
Your employment contract is the starting point. Check:
If you have been working from home for an extended period and your employer has accepted this without objection, there is an argument that a contractual variation has occurred by conduct. Changing back to office-only working against your wishes would then require your agreement or a process of formal consultation.
If your employer simply announces you must return to the office without consultation and without following a proper process, you may have grounds to challenge this — either as a breach of contract or, in some circumstances, as constructive dismissal if the change is significant enough.
Since April 2024, the right to request flexible working — which includes requests for home working — changed significantly under the Employment Relations (Flexible Working) Act 2023:
The eight grounds on which an employer can refuse include burden of additional costs, detrimental effect on the ability to meet customer demand, inability to reorganise work among existing staff, and others. An employer who refuses without citing one of these grounds is acting unlawfully.
Crucially, the law gives you the right to ask — not the right to receive. An employer who cites a valid business reason and follows the correct process can refuse your request. However, they must genuinely consider it.
There are circumstances where an employer's refusal of home working may be unlawful:
Under the Equality Act 2010, employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments for employees with disabilities. If your disability makes commuting difficult or means you can work more effectively from home, refusing to allow home working may amount to a failure to make reasonable adjustments — which is unlawful discrimination.
Conditions that may trigger this duty include long-term physical health conditions, chronic fatigue, anxiety, depression, and many other impairments with a substantial and long-term effect on daily activities.
A blanket refusal of flexible working requests that disproportionately affects women — including mothers returning from maternity leave — may constitute indirect sex discrimination if the employer cannot justify it.
While there is no specific right to work from home for parents or carers, indirect discrimination arguments can apply if a "return to office" requirement disproportionately impacts women (who statistically carry a greater share of childcare responsibilities) and cannot be objectively justified.
If your employer refuses your request or fails to follow the correct process:
Compensation for a successful flexible working claim can be up to eight weeks' pay (capped at the statutory weekly pay limit).
There is no automatic legal obligation for employers to provide home working equipment, though many do. However:
If your employer wants to require a return to the office after a period of agreed home working:
A unilateral instruction to return to the office, issued without consultation or reasonable notice, is unlikely to be legally watertight — particularly where home working has been in place for a significant period.
Many employers now operate hybrid models. If a hybrid arrangement has been agreed and forms part of your terms and conditions, your employer cannot unilaterally change it any more than they could change your salary or holiday entitlement.
Get any hybrid working arrangement confirmed in writing. An email confirmation is sufficient. A verbal agreement is harder to prove if challenged.
Received a return-to-office policy or had your flexible working request refused? Upload the document to fairead for a plain-English analysis of whether your employer's position is legally sound.
Upload any UK legal document and get an instant AI breakdown — clause by clause, risk by risk, in plain English.
Related Guides
Non-compete clauses are common in UK employment contracts — but many are unenforceable. Here's how to tell whether yours would hold up in court, and what you can do about it.
Not all employment contracts are created equal. These 10 clauses are commonly misunderstood, frequently overreaching, and sometimes unenforceable — here's what to look for.
If you're being made redundant, UK law entitles you to statutory redundancy pay — but many employees don't know how to calculate it or what else they're owed. Here's the full picture.